"A photograph diligent finished a scanning electron microscope of a CI1 meteorite (ASSESS) is within walking distance in substance and achieve approach to the giant bacterium Titanospirillum velox (MISSING), an soul found stage on planet Nest, a NASA scientist understood."Out of the ordinary Glisten in Meteorites: colossal Exploit or 'Garbage'?"Gripe 7th, 2011 FoxNews.comA NASA scientist announced a evil attain Friday, claiming a out of the ordinary meteorite holds the fossilized evidence of alien life. But is the work a "COLOSSAL DEED," as one scientist put it? Or in the homily of changed, modestly "dissipate"?Dr. Richard B. Hoover, an astrobiologist with NASA's Marshall Impassive Recoil Fundamental, is confident that he has found fossils internal an absolutely out of the ordinary class of meteorites, called CI1 carbonaceous chondrites. He published his latest consequence in the Gripe problem of the online Announcement of Cosmology -- research that suggests we are not on your own in the universe, he told FoxNews.com."I make notes on it as indicating that life is better extensively disperse than slender in fact to the planet Nest," Hoover understood. "This domain of inspect has closely definitely been touched -- for example quite honestly, a climax heap scientist would say that this is outmoded."Expecting disorder, the appraise issued individual invitations to 100 scientists asking them to compare in on the finding. Now the appraise itself has convert the origin of disorder. On Monday, a NASA supplication by Paul Hertz, manager scientist in the science course group, understood Hoover spoiled to report the agency he had submitted the paper to the Announcement of Cosmology -- and that the article spoiled to get published in a better rigid peer-reviewed appraise. Others place to a history of "OUT PRESENT-DAY" science stories, and mention that the Journal's website is unskilled. Blogger and Scholarly of Minnesota natural scientist PZ Myers called it "the ginned-up website of a little group of lift academics."Editor Lana Tao absolutely fought buoy up, inclination such clarification "tantamount to school-yard hissing by greedy childish."The ad hominem attacks and complaints by make somewhere your home ["that"] say Dr. Hoover's article could do with stick been published in these other periodicals, and not JOC, are closely adverse grapes and could do with not be diligent basically," she Tao understood.The Announcement published into the future Monday start 12 responses, understood Dr. Rudy Schild, a scientist with the Harvard-Smithsonian's Fundamental for Astrophysics and Cosmology's editor-in-chief.He claimed that "NO ANNOTATIONS HAS ON THE BALL OUT ANY BASIC FLAWS IN THE DATA." Diverse scientists stick for certain voiced concerns, nevertheless, closely not to the Announcement itself -- in spite of the right give the right for argue.David Morrison, boss scientist at the NASA Astrobiology Set off at Ames Cram Fundamental, told MSNBC he felt the privileged of specialized appraise was tolerable to give the right the report now material."Striking claims make piercing evidence. At a nude minimum this would make news item in a desirable peer-refereed specialized appraise -- which this is not."Almost certainly the news item came out too soon; better entitlement would stick been on April 1," Morrison new.Diverse scientists and writers stick referenced the provide backing work in this domain, and within walking distance claims of life in meteorites -- every the 1960s claims by Fordham Scholarly chemist Bartholomew Nagy as well as provide backing claims by Dr. Hoover through in 2004 and 2007.NASA science manager Hertz seconded make somewhere your home statements. "NEVERTHELESS WE BE AWARE OF THE FREE DROP A LINE TO OF IDEAS, DATA, AND INFORMATION AS PHASE OF SPECIALIZED AND RITUAL ANALYSIS, NASA CANNOT STAND BRINGING UP THE REAR OR SUPPORT A SPECIALIZED CONTROL UNLESS IT HAS BEEN PEER-REVIEWED OR WHOLLY EXAMINED BY OTHER CERTIFIED EXPERTS," Mr Hertz understood.From the Announcement of Cosmology...SynopsisOrganic (ESEM) and Rule Pus Scanning Electron Microscopy (FESEM) investigations of the median surfaces of the CI1 Carbonaceous Meteorites stick yielded images of large full of twists and turns filaments. The filaments stick been observed to be entrenched in of late broken median surfaces of the sand. They portray temperament (E.G., THE SUBSTANCE AND SUBSTANCE RANGES OF THE MEDIAN CELLS AND THEIR NATURAL WORLD AND USUAL INTERNAL SHEATHS) that are analytical of overfriendly genera and individual of trichomic cyanobacteria and other trichomic prokaryotes such as the filamentous sulfur bacteria. ESEM and FESEM studies of time and relic cyanobacteria show within walking distance temperament in uniseriate and multiseriate, branched or unbranched, isodiametric or fine, polarized or unpolarized filaments with trichomes encased internal thin or opaque external sheaths. Filaments found in the CI1 meteorites stick in the same way been detected that portray structures even with the scientific cells and structures used by cyanobacteria for carry (BAEOCYTES, AKINETES AND HORMOGONIA), nitrogen compound (BASAL, INTERCALARY OR APICAL HETEROCYSTS) and opinion or motility (FIMBRIAE). Energy dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS) studies indicate that the meteorite filaments are ordinarily carbon profitable sheaths infilled with magnesium sulfate and other minerals unusual of the CI1 carbonaceous meteorites. The substance, approach, detailed morphological makeup and chemical compositions of the meteorite filaments are not even with overfriendly individual of minerals. The nitrogen joyful of the meteorite filaments are throughout ever in the gratitude limit of the EDS detector. EDS appraisal of terrestrial minerals and biological goods (E.G., TOUGH EPSOMITE, FILAMENTOUS CYANOBACTERIA; MUMMY AND VAST HAIR/TISSUES, AND FOSSILS OF CYANOBACTERIA, TRILOBITES, INSECTS IN AMBER) indicate that nitrogen cadaver appreciable in biological goods for thousands of energy but is disguised in the ancient fossils. These studies stick led to the join that the filaments found in the CI1 carbonaceous meteorites are home fossils totally than place terrestrial biological contaminants that entered the meteorites after yield on Nest. The ?13C and D/H joyful of amino acids and other organics found in these sand are prevented to be even with the depiction that comets denote the parent bodies of the CI1 carbonaceous meteorites. The implications of the gratitude of fossils of cyanobacteria in the CI1 meteorites to the opening of life on comets, Europa and Enceladus are discussed."Fossils of Cyanobacteria in CI1 Carbonaceous Meteorites: Implications to Glisten on Comets, Europa, and Enceladus" by Richard B. HooverAnd this..."Scientists call off alien life report"A NASA bookish says he has found relic bacteria in meteorites, but fixed his employer declines to stand bringing up the rear that control.by Thomas H. Maugh IIGripe 7th, 2011Los Angeles Get olderA report claiming to attain have a break of alien life in meteorites has been extensively dismissed by scientists after its news item Friday in an revolutionary online appraise.The report was written by Richard Hoover, an produce at NASA's Marshall Impassive Recoil Fundamental in Huntsville, Ala.. He had sliced right a hitch-hike of little meteorites, looked at them under a microscope and seen what he supposed were the fossils of slight bacteria called cyanobacteria.Hoover wrote his report, last that life is well-known in the course of the universe. He submitted a paper to the Announcement of Astrobiology, which rejected it.Hoover then sent his paper to the online Announcement of Cosmology, which promotes the zest that life on Nest came from peripheral space. A report by Fox Data on the paper triggered a meteor twister of breathe heavily over the weekend followed nimbly by ridicule by best part scientists.NASA has distanced itself from Hoover's work. In an inquiring step Monday, Paul Hertz, manager scientist of NASA's science career directorate, issued a supplication express wish, among other objects, that "NASA cannot stand bringing up the rear or support a specialized control unless it has been peer-reviewed or wholly examined by other certified experts.... NASA was ignorant of the recent attention of the paper to the Announcement of Cosmology or of the paper's later news item."The Announcement of Cosmology is a 2-year-old news item apt by Rudy Schild of the Harvard-Smithsonian Fundamental for Astrophysics that has unabashedly promoted the piece that life exists in the course of the universe and was brought to Nest from off. The appraise has published closely 13 issues and, in a news release Monday, understood it would end news item in May, "KILLED BY THIEVES AND CROOKS" at the appraise Science and other subscription-based periodicals, whom it has accused of fogged up its skill to disclose news.The Announcement of Cosmology claims to be peer-reviewed. In this case, the journal's editors understood it had sent a aura of Hoover's article to 100 garish scientists for critiques and would matter them as they spring in. In normal specialized publishing, sound encapsulate is conducted in the future a paper is published to secure veracity.The dues of scientists, for the paramount phase, has been bleak. "I'M SURPRISED CHARACTER IS SPECIAL CONSIDERATION IT ANY AUTHORITY AT ALL," wrote blogger and natural scientist Paul Z. Myers of the Scholarly of Minnesota."Find fluff nation. There's vacuum to see stage," wrote Rosie Redfield, a microbiologist at the Scholarly of British Columbia, express wish that it is clean to attain structures in style that rise within walking distance to bacteria."This appears to be science by wishful set," Redfield understood in a scream listeners.Hoover has not responded to media requests for interviews.Others understood that fixed if the traces Hoover spotted in the meteorite could do with sustain to be bacteria, it would be thick-skinned to attitude out infectivity.This is not the first time that researchers stick claimed to attain fossils in a meteorite. In 1996, a NASA bookish - this time with the agency's imprimatur - understood he had found relic bacteria in a meteorite that had been darned off the surface of Mars. The report, which was published in the appraise Science, was featured on the cover of Phase magazine and was trumpeted by the Ice-covered Lay.At the end of the day, nevertheless, most scientists absolute that what researchers had seen were merely rock formations that looked resembling fossils.Concluding day, NASA-sponsored researchers understood they had discovered that indisputable bacteria in Mono Swimming pool in California may well transfer arsenic now their DNA in settle of phosphorus, arguing that the finding indicated the opening of inquiring life forms in space. That join in the same way was derided by other scientists.
Posted by Unknown
|
at
10:42 AM
